Pro-active AWR Data Mining to find change in SQL Execution Plan

Posted in: Technical Track

Many times we have been called for the poor performance of a database and it has been narrowed down to a  SQL statement. Subsequent analysis have shown that the execution plan has been changed and a wrong execution plan was being used.

Resolution normally, is to fix the execution plan in 11g by running

variable x number
:x :=

or for 10g, SQL_PROFILE is created as mentioned in Carlos Sierra’s blog .

A pro-active approach can be to mine AWR data for any SQL execution plan changes.

Following query from dba_hist_sqlstat can retrieve the list of SQL IDs whose plans have changed. It orders the SQL IDs,so that those SQL IDs for which maximum gains can be achieved by fixing plan, are listed first.

spool sql_with_more_than_1plan.txt
set lines 220 pages 9999 trimspool on
set numformat 999,999,999
column plan_hash_value format 99999999999999
column min_snap format 999999
column max_snap format 999999
column min_avg_ela format 999,999,999,999,999
column avg_ela format 999,999,999,999,999
column ela_gain format 999,999,999,999,999
select sql_id,
       min(min_snap_id) min_snap,
       max(max_snap_id) max_snap,
       max(decode(rw_num,1,plan_hash_value)) plan_hash_value,
       max(decode(rw_num,1,avg_ela)) min_avg_ela,
       avg(avg_ela) avg_ela,
       avg(avg_ela) - max(decode(rw_num,1,avg_ela)) ela_gain,
       -- max(decode(rw_num,1,avg_buffer_gets)) min_avg_buf_gets,
       -- avg(avg_buffer_gets) avg_buf_gets,
       max(decode(rw_num,1,sum_exec))-1 min_exec,
       avg(sum_exec)-1 avg_exec
from (
  select sql_id, plan_hash_value, avg_buffer_gets, avg_ela, sum_exec,
         row_number() over (partition by sql_id order by avg_ela) rw_num , min_snap_id, max_snap_id
    select sql_id, plan_hash_value , sum(BUFFER_GETS_DELTA)/(sum(executions_delta)+1) avg_buffer_gets,
    sum(elapsed_time_delta)/(sum(executions_delta)+1) avg_ela, sum(executions_delta)+1 sum_exec,
    min(snap_id) min_snap_id, max(snap_id) max_snap_id
    from dba_hist_sqlstat a
    where exists  (
       select sql_id from dba_hist_sqlstat b where a.sql_id = b.sql_id
         and  a.plan_hash_value != b.plan_hash_value
         and  b.plan_hash_value > 0)
    and plan_hash_value > 0
    group by sql_id, plan_hash_value
    order by sql_id, avg_ela
  order by sql_id, avg_ela
group by sql_id
having max(decode(rw_num,1,sum_exec)) > 1
order by 7 desc
spool off
clear columns
set numformat 9999999999

The sample output for this query will look like

SQL_ID        MIN_SNAP MAX_SNAP PLAN_HASH_VALUE          MIN_AVG_ELA              AVG_ELA             ELA_GAIN     MIN_EXEC     AVG_EXEC
------------- -------- -------- --------------- -------------------- -------------------- -------------------- ------------ ------------
ba42qdzhu5jb0    65017    67129      2819751536       11,055,899,019       90,136,403,552       79,080,504,532           12            4
2zm7y3tvqygx5    65024    67132       362220407       14,438,575,143       34,350,482,006       19,911,906,864            1            3
74j7px7k16p6q    65029    67134      1695658241       24,049,644,247       30,035,372,306        5,985,728,059           14            7
dz243qq1wft49    65030    67134      3498253836        1,703,657,774        7,249,309,870        5,545,652,097            1            2

MIN_SNAP and MAX_SNAP are the minimum/maximum snap id where the SQL statement occurs

PLAN_HASH_VALUE is the hash_value of the plan with the best elapsed time

ELA_GAIN is the estimated improvement in elapsed time by using this plan compared to the average execution time.

Using the output of the above query, sql execution plans can be fixed, after proper testing.  This method can help DBAs pin-point and resolve problems with SQL execution plans, faster.

Want to talk with an expert? Schedule a call with our team to get the conversation started.

4 Comments. Leave new

Looks interesting. Just want to make sure I understand. You take the PLAN_HASH_VALUE in the query and use this in the dbms_spm.load_plans_from_cursor_cache function?

Joseph Amalraj
July 24, 2014 2:08 pm

That’s correct. Have done this many times, when there is a report of a query performing badly.

oracleman consulting
June 24, 2015 10:58 pm

just to follow the example:

variable x number
:x :=


and it would fix ba42qdzhu5jb0?

Joseph Amalraj
June 30, 2015 7:50 am

Yes that should fix the plan, if the plan is available in the cursor cache. If the plan is stored in AWR tables, you can use DBMS_SPM.LOAD_PLANS_FROM_SQLSET to store sql baselines. The sql statements with the correct plan can be put in the sqlset using DBMS_SQLTUNE.LOAD_SQLSET.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *